The Fantasy Quarterback Conundrum: Who to Start, Who to Bench?
In the world of NFL Fantasy, making lineup decisions can be a nerve-wracking task. Fear not, fantasy managers! We're here to guide you through the tricky choices for Week 16. But here's where it gets controversial... some of these picks might surprise you!
Let's dive into the quarterback options, starting with the bold and the brilliant.
Start 'Em
Jacoby Brissett: Last week, Brissett proved his mettle against the formidable Texans defense, emerging as the top-scoring quarterback. Now, he faces the Falcons, who have been generous to opposing passers. With the Bengals on the horizon in the championship week, Brissett is a solid choice. As my colleague Marcas Grant would say, 'Brissett it and forget it' - a strategy that could pay dividends.
Jared Goff: Goff and the Detroit Lions have found their groove late in the season. Since Week 10, Goff has been on fire, throwing multiple touchdowns and racking up yards. The Lions are in a must-win situation, so expect them to keep the pedal to the metal. Goff faces the Steelers, who have been vulnerable to quarterbacks, making him a strong starter.
Jordan Love: Love has been a consistent presence in our Start 'Em articles, and for good reason. While his performances can vary, his predictability based on matchups is a valuable asset. This week, he takes on the Bears, who have struggled against the pass. Chicago's recent tendency to play man coverage and blitz more frequently plays right into Love's strengths. He's a solid option for those seeking a reliable quarterback.
Bryce Young: Young and the Panthers have been on a rollercoaster ride, but he's shown improved consistency lately. His running game has been a welcome addition, and the matchup against the Bucs is enticing. Tampa Bay has been generous to quarterbacks, allowing plenty of passing yards and touchdowns. Young's performance against this defense last year adds to his appeal. He's a deep dive option for those in need of a quarterback.
Sit 'Em
Jaxson Dart: Dart is a talented player, but the Vikings matchup is a tough ask. Minnesota's defense has been stingy, allowing few passing yards and touchdowns. Brian Flores' unit has been particularly tough lately. While Dart has upside with his legs, he's not a must-start this week. I'd opt for Brissett, Goff, Love, or even Purdy and Nix ahead of him.
Trevor Lawrence: Lawrence has been on a roll since Week 8, but his recent performances against tougher defenses have been less impressive. This week, he faces the Broncos, who have been a tough nut to crack for quarterbacks. It's best to avoid this matchup and not chase last week's fantasy points.
Caleb Williams: Williams has the potential for big games, but his floor is worryingly low. This week, he goes up against the Packers, who held him in check just two weeks ago. With the Packers struggling against the run, expect the Bears to focus on that aspect. Given Williams' recent struggles, it might be wise to look elsewhere for fantasy points.
Sam Darnold: Darnold has shown flashes of brilliance, but his inconsistency can be costly. In recent games, he's failed to reach double-digit fantasy points, which is a risky proposition in the fantasy semifinals. His worst performance came against the Rams, a game that highlighted his vulnerability. I'd recommend rolling the dice on Young or one of the streaming options mentioned earlier.
So, fantasy managers, who are you starting and sitting this week? Remember, these decisions can make or break your season. Let us know your thoughts in the comments! Are there any controversial picks you'd like to discuss?
